Chocolate In the Oven Bake Shop

Really delicious pie! Also had a lobster tail that was super fresh and had the perfect filling. Will make the drive to come back soon and try more!

This is everything I want in a bake shoppe. While I tend to use the phrase “oh, my god,” when I feel I’ve died and gone to Heaven, it certainly seems a contradiction in terms considering the sinfully rich selection of desserts offered. When you want to be bad, this is the place to go.

Chocolate in the Oven is that perfect little center of town bakery. It is big enough for a wonderful assortment of treats, yet small enough to make you feel exactly like a kid in a candy shoppe. Colorful confections fill their perfectly displayed cases, leaving you longing for one of each.

Immediately upon entering, before my eyes was a devilishly decadent looking chocolate chip cookie cheesecake square. Perhaps it was just as well that I didn’t look around further before making my selection. However, while it was being packaged I couldn’t help but notice how amazing the cupcakes looked a couple inches away and added to my order (for my family). When everything was boxed and paid for, I allowed my eyes to wander further and continued to drool.

All good reviews generally include pictures. But all I could think about was diving into my cheesecake square which I finished within a mile of leaving, while cruising the equally appealing and lovely streets of Milford.

Strategically speaking, I have a reason to go back for the sole purpose of taking pictures 😉

For the record, I am a lover of cheesecake and chocolate chip cookies. And in this combination, one plus one equals a ten! The first bite was everything I expected and more. Plus, it was possible to hold it like a cookie to eat while I was driving. Although it was big enough to have cut into four smaller squares, it kept beckoning to me at each red light I hit. Absolute perfection.

Visiting Chocolate in the Oven is a sensory experience, and the expectation is not only met, but far exceeded. Even their boxes are appealing.

Hats off to their baker, Meredith, who I interviewed for an article I was writing about their cookie fundraiser for a local Special Olympics athlete. They had put the athlete’s image on cookies, and proceeds were going to her team. I actually went in to buy these cookies, which I am happy to say I did as well. A business that gives back to the community is an A-class establishment.

I can’t wait to go back. This bakery is now my gold standard.

I've been to this bakery a few times now and they have great service and coffee! I recently ordered a custom cake and it was beautiful and delicious! It turned out even better than expected! I highly recommend this place.

I have been ordering my special occasion cakes from Chocolate in the oven for about two years now. The cakes are always beautiful and delicious. Most bakeries can’t achieve both. It’s usually pretty but taste terrible. Or Vice a versa. I just had them make a vanilla naked cake with raspberry mousse filling for my daughters baby shower. The most delicious cake I have ever had!!!! Thank you so much!!!

Amazing bakery with lots of amazing sweets! So much to looks at and choose from! From hot coco bombs to huge cakes and pies, to decorate your own cookie kits, they have it all! Huge selection of single baked goods, cupcakes, truffles, gingerbread cookies, biscotti, magic cookie bars, pecan bars and so much more. Wonderfully decorated for the season. Only reason I gave four stars was the price, one decorated sugar cookie was $4.50, way to much for just one cookie. Stop by tho if you're not on a budget, everything looked super yummy!